Skip to main content

SETWorks

Workforce First

A Technology-Powered Guide to the DSP Crisis

DSP turnover is an operational problem as much as a structural one. Explore the research, retention strategies, and how purpose-built technology can help.

Table of Contents

Download the Workforce-First Toolkit; a practical implementation guide with 15 tools, templates, and worksheets!

If you’re leading an IDD agency today, chances are the DSP workforce crisis isn’t something you’ve only read about, but something you experience every day.
 
Every open shift, every overtime request, every declined referral, and every resignation affect your organization, your staff, and the people you support. Recruiting has become more difficult. Retention has become even harder. And for many agencies, it can feel like you’re constantly rebuilding a workforce that’s already stretched too thin.
 
Direct support professionals (DSPs) are the foundation of disability services. They help people with intellectual and developmental disabilities (IDD) live, work, and participate in their communities. They support everything from personal care and medication administration to employment, community inclusion, relationship building, and independent living. Their work is deeply personal, highly skilled, and essential to making person-centered services possible.
 
Despite the critical role they play, agencies across the country continue to lose DSPs faster than they can replace them.

Today, more than 500,000 people with IDD are on waiting lists for services they’ve already been approved to receive. Source: ANCOR

Purpose-built technology can remove many of the obstacles that contribute to burnout, improve the daily work experience, and give DSPs more time to focus on the reason they entered this profession: supporting people. While it won't solve every dimension of the workforce crisis — it's a lever agencies can actually pull.

This guide explores the current state of the DSP workforce, the research behind why DSPs leave, and the operational strategies agencies can use to build a stronger, more sustainable workforce.

Part 1: The Scale of the Crisis: What the Data Tells Us

The direct support workforce crisis didn’t emerge overnight. Instead, it’s the result of decades of structural challenges, including chronic workforce shortages, increasing demand for community-based services, and shifting Medicaid reimbursement rates that have struggled to keep pace with inflation and rising operating costs.

Because DSP wages are largely funded through Medicaid, many agencies face a difficult reality: they recognize the need to increase wages and invest more in their workforce, but have limited financial flexibility to do so without broader policy changes.

The result is a workforce under extraordinary pressure, and the data reflects it.

The DSP workforce crisis didn’t happen overnight. It’s the result of long-term structural challenges that continue to affect agencies, DSPs, and the people they support.

The numbers are striking on their own, but their impact extends far beyond agency operations. Every vacancy represents more than an unfilled position: it’s additional overtime for existing staff, delayed services for individuals waiting for support, increased administrative pressure on supervisors, more time spent recruiting instead of training, and in many cases, difficult decisions about limiting referrals/intakes or reducing programs.

For the people receiving services, and for the professionals supporting them, the impact of the workforce crisis is felt everyday.

The effects of DSP turnover reach every corner of an organization.

The workforce crisis is often described as a staffing problem rather than a retention problem. Recruiting is important, but replacing experienced DSPs year after year is expensive, disruptive, and emotionally taxing for agencies, supervisors, the individuals receiving services, and the DSPs who remain.

The next question to ask is: Why do DSPs leave in the first place?

Part 2: Why DSPs Leave: The Root Causes Beyond Wages

When discussions about the DSP workforce crisis begin, compensation almost always comes first – and for good reason. Low Medicaid reimbursement rates have limited agencies’ ability to increase wages for decades. This is one of the most significant structural challenges facing disability service providers, and meaningful progress will require continued policy advocacy at both the state and federal levels.

 

However, compensation is only part of the story. Research consistently shows that turnover is the result of an accumulation of daily experiences: paperwork that feels disconnected from the work, unpredictable schedules, limited opportunities for growth, and the emotional weight of supporting people while feeling unsupported themselves.

 

Understanding these daily experiences is essential because they represent of the greatest opportunities agencies have to improve retention. While many external factors remain outside of an individual provider’s control, the daily work environment is something organization leaders can actively shape.

So what is making the work harder than it needs to be?
Turnover is rarely caused by a single issue. Instead, it’s the cumulative effect of several interconnected challenges.
1. Administrative Burden That Feels Disconnected From the Mission

Documentation is an essential part of delivering quality services. It supports continuity of care, demonstrates outcomes, satisfies compliance requirements, and ensures agencies receive reimbursement for the services they provide.

The challenge many DSPs experience with documentation is how much unnecessary work it often entails. DSPs may complete service notes, goal tracking, EVV requirements, incident reports, mileage logs, medication records, and other documentation throughout a shift. When those responsibilities are spread across multiple systems, or require entering the same information more than once, they become burdensome.

Every additional login, duplicate entry, or manual workaround consumes valuable time and mental energy that could otherwise be spent supporting individuals.

Administrative burden is a well-documented driver of burnout across healthcare and human services and DSP roles are no exception. DSPs consistently report that documentation feels increasingly disconnected from the work that drew them to the profession in the first place.

People enter the DSP workforce because they want to make a difference in someone’s life, not because they want their days to be filled with paperwork. When administrative work begins to overshadow that purpose, job satisfaction naturally begins to erode.

Every additional administrative step competes with the time DSPs spend supporting people

The workforce transformation community has increasingly recognized technology as part of the solution, but only when it genuinely reduces workload instead of adding another layer of complexity.

2. Scheduling Chaos & Unpredictability

Few things make work-life balance more difficult than never knowing what tomorrow’s schedule will look like. When staffing shortages persist, providers often rely on their most dependable DSPs to fill open shifts, work overtime, and respond to last-minute schedule changes. While this helps maintain services in the short term, it also places tremendous pressure on the very employees agencies are trying hardest to retain.

Over time, that pattern becomes difficult to sustain. Research from GoodLife U reinforces what agency leaders have observed for years: most DSPs don’t leave because they no longer care about the work, they leave because the pace becomes unsustainable.

Unpredictable schedules affect more than employee satisfaction. They make it harder for DSPs to plan childcare, attend appointments, pursue education, or simply recharge between shifts.

Without intervention, staffing shortages can create a cycle that continually reinforces itself.

The impact extends to the people receiving services as well. Consistent relationships are one of the foundations of person-centered support. Frequent schedule changes and rotating staff can disrupt routines, reduce continuity, and make it more difficult to build the trust that quality services depend on. Retention, therefore, isn’t only about keeping positions filled, it’s about preserving relationships and maintaining a community.

3. Lack of Recognition & Career Visibility

When ANCOR interviewed dozens of DSPs about what would improve their jobs, the most consistent response was recognition. Beyond formal awards or incentive programs, DSPs expressed they wanted leadership to understand what their work looked like each day.

This suggests that retention isn’t solely driven by compensation or workload, but it’s also influenced by whether people feel valued, supported, and connected to the mission of the organization.

Similarly, lack of options for career growth in this field presents a challenge. For many DSPs, there are limited opportunities to advance after they reach a certain point without leaving direct support altogether. Clear developmental pathways, additional certifications, mentoring opportunities, and leadership roles help reinforce that DSP work is a profession and won’t be capped at entry-level. When people can see a future within an organization, they’re far more likely to build one there.

4. The Weight of Invisibility

Few professions have as much impact on people’s daily lives while receiving so little public recognition. DSPs support individuals during some of life’s most meaningful and critical moments: finding employment, building relationships, participating in their communities, achieving greater independence, and navigating everyday challenges.

However, the profession remains widely understood. Many people outside the disability services field couldn’t describe what a DSP does on a typical day, and that lack of visbility has real consequences because it influences public perception, workforce investment, reimbursement discussions, resource allocation, and recruitment efforts.

As one DSP put it when describing the tension at the heart of the workforce crisis, “We love our organization’s services and our clients, but we have to feed our families”. Commitment to the mission is incredibly present in the workforce, but commitment alone isn’t enough to sustain it.

5. The Compounding Effect on Those Who Stay

Every departure reshapes the experiences of employees who remain: open shifts are redistributed, documentation responsibilities increase, supervisors spend more time covering direct support instead of coaching their teams, quality initiatives get delayed, and recruitment becomes the priority instead of development.

ANCOR’s 2025 workforce survey found that 62 percent of providers reported struggling to achieve quality standards. This isn’t because quality mattered less, but because staffing shortages made maintaining those standards increasingly difficult.

This is why retention is the most crucial focus: we must create environments where experienced DSPs can continue doing meaningful work without carrying an ever-growing operational burden.

Looking across these challenges, it can be observed that these problems are operational. Operational problems are often shaped, either positively or negatively, by the systems providers rely on daily. While technology won’t solve the workforce crisis on its own, it can remove many of the unnecessary barriers that make an already demanding job even more difficult.

Part 3: Technology's Role in DSP Retention (How Software Either Hurts or Helps)

The goal of technology’s involvement in the solution of the workforce crisis is not to replace human relationships with technology, but to reduce administrative friction so DSPs can spend their time and energy on supporting people.

Technology has become part of nearly every aspect of disability services, but not all technology improves the daily experience of the people using it. Disconnected software systems create duplicate work, unnecessary logins, manual reconciliation, and fragmented workflows.

Purpose-built IDD technology connects scheduling, documentation, EVV, billing, and reporting so information flows naturally from one task to the next. Every minute saved becomes more time available for supporting people.

Documentation Should Work For DSPs, Not Against Them

As one of the cornerstone’s of a DSPs workload, documentation should reinforce quality services instead of competing with them. Purpose-built software platforms reduce duplicate entry, support mobile documentation, integrate EVV, and help DSPs document in the natural flow of their work.

Questions for Leaders:

  • How many systems does a DSP use during one shift?
  • How much documentation happens after the shift ends?
  • Where is information entered more than once?
Scheduling That Respects DSP Time

Scheduling is more than filling shifts, it’s preserving consistency for staff and the individuals they support. Integrated scheduling helps leaders identify gaps earlier, distribute workload more equitably, and reduce burnout.

Questions for Leaders:

  • How often are shifts filled at the last minute?
  • Are the same DSPs consistently working overtime?
  • How consistent are staff assignments?
Training & Onboarding That Builds Commitment Early

The first 90 days of a DSPs job are critical. Technology helps agencies deliver consistent onboarding, monitor training progress, and support career development from day one.

Questions for Leaders:

  • What does a DSP experience in the first 90 days?
  • Is the onboarding process replicable for scale?
  • Can staff see a path for growth?
Data Visibility That Helps Leaders Act Earlier

Good reporting isn’t just beneficial for compliance, but it also helps supervisors identify trends before they become turnover and allows them to intervene earlier.

Questions for Leaders:

  • Which metrics do leaders review?
  • Where do the metrics live and how are they tracked?
  • Which reports lead to action and how?
Every minute you give back to a DSP is a minute spent on the people they support.

The most successful disability service organizations aren’t trying to solve every workforce challenge at once. Instead, they identify one source of unnecessary friction, improve it, measure results, and build from there. That is where implementation begins.

Part 4: The Workforce First Framework

Rather than asking, “How do we solve the workforce crisis?” start with a simpler question: “What can we make easier for our DSPs tomorrow?” Small improvements compound over time. Take a peek at the framework below or download the full Workforce-First Framework Toolkit.

The five aspects of the Workforce-First Framework

  1. Understand
    Start by understanding where administrative friction exists today. Listen to DSPs, observe workflows, and map where time is lost to duplicate work, disconnected systems, and unnecessary processes. Start here:
  • Hold short listening sessions or open office hours with DSPs
  • Map a typical shift from start to finish
  • Identify duplicate documentation, unnecessary clicks, and disconnected workflows

Conversation starter: “If I could eliminate one frustrating task from your shift tomorrow, what would it be?”

Get the Administrative Friction Audit worksheet and DSP interview guide here!

2. Simplify
Before adding new technology, simplify the workflow itself. Every unnecessary step removed is time returned to direct support. Start here:

  • Look for duplicate forms or approvals
  • Reduce manual data entry wherever possible
  • Standardize documentation processes across teams

Quick check: how many systems, logins, and clicks does it take a DSP to complete one visit?

Not sure where to start? Download the Workflow Simplification Checklist here!

3. Connect
Disconnected systems created disconnected experiences. Connected workflows reduce rework and improve visibility across the organization. Start here:

  • Evaluate where information is entered more than once
  • Connect scheduling documentation, EVV, billing, and reporting
  • Look for opportunities to eliminate manual reconciliation

Tip: Think in workflows, not software modules.

Grab a Connected Workflow Mapping Template here!

4. Support
Technology is only part of retention. The strongest agencies pair efficient workflows with engaged leadership and meaningful staff support. Start here:

  • Schedule regular one-on-one check-ins
  • Recognize and celebrate great work consistently
  • Create visible career pathways and mentoring opportunities

Conversation starter: “What part of your work gives you the most energy? What consistently slows you down?”

Looking for more conversation starters? Check out the Interview Guide and Supervisor Conversation Toolkit here.

5. Measure
Retention is an ongoing process. Track the changes you’re making and celebrate progress along the way. Start here:

  • Monitor turnover, vacancies, overtime, documentation time, and staff feedback
  • Review trends regularly
  • Adjust based on what your data and your staff tell you

Tip: Start with a few meaningful metrics instead of trying to measure everything at once.

Download the Workforce KPI Dashboard and 90-Day Action Planner here.

Conclusion

The DSP workforce crisis is one of the defining challenges facing disability service providers today. While agencies cannot solve every structural issue affecting the workforce, they can shape the experience of the people who choose to do this important work. Every streamlined workflow, every unnecessary click eliminated, every hour returned to direct support contributes to a stronger workforce and better outcomes for the individuals agencies serve.

Technology isn’t the solution by itself. But when technology is purpose-built around the realities of IDD services, it becomes a powerful tool for supporting the people who make those services possible.

For organizations ready to put this framework into practice, the Workforce-First Toolkit provides detailed worksheets, conversation guides, templates, and implementation tools for every step.

Download the Workforce-First Toolkit,

a practical implementation guide with 15 tools, templates, and worksheets!

Ready to see it all in one place?

SETWorks is built to manage your entire organization, from client records to billing to compliance, without juggling multiple systems.

 

Connect with our team to learn how our purpose-built software platform created specifically for disability services can empower your agency.

Schedule a Call

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the average DSP turnover rate?

The national DSP turnover rate hovers near 40% annually, with vacancy rates ranging between 12% and 15%, according to ANCOR's 2025 State of America's Direct Support Workforce Crisis report. These figures have remained stubbornly high for over two decades, despite periods of modest improvement.

Why do DSPs leave their jobs?

DSPs leave for a combination of reasons that go beyond wages. Low pay driven by inadequate Medicaid reimbursement rates is a major factor, but administrative burden, unpredictable scheduling, lack of recognition, and limited career advancement all contribute significantly. Many DSPs enter the field because they want to make a difference in someone's life. When the daily reality of the job becomes dominated by paperwork, chaotic hours, and little support, that purpose erodes and turnover follows.

What causes DSP burnout?

DSP burnout is typically caused by a combination of physically and emotionally demanding work, inconsistent or unpredictable scheduling, excessive administrative documentation, and inadequate staffing that forces remaining staff to cover additional shifts. These pressures compound over time: as agencies lose DSPs to burnout, the DSPs who stay absorb more of the workload, accelerating burnout further in a cycle that's difficult to break without operational change.

How do you reduce DSP turnover?

Reducing DSP turnover requires addressing both structural and operational factors. While agencies have limited control over Medicaid reimbursement rates, they can meaningfully improve the daily work experience by reducing administrative burden, creating more consistent and predictable scheduling, investing in training and career pathways, and using data to identify burnout risk before it leads to resignation. Purpose-built technology can address several of these levers at once by removing friction from day-to-day workflows.

What software features help reduce administrative burden?

The software features that most effectively reduce administrative burden for DSPs include integrated documentation that captures service notes, EVV, and goal tracking in a single workflow; mobile-friendly interfaces that don't require a desktop computer; automatic syncing between documentation and billing so information is never entered twice; and scheduling tools that give supervisors visibility into gaps and overtime before they become a crisis. The common thread is integration: features that eliminate duplicate work rather than adding another system to manage.

What should agencies look for in IDD software?

Agencies evaluating IDD software should look for a platform purpose-built for the disability services industry rather than adapted from general-purpose healthcare or human services software. Key considerations include integrated documentation and EVV, scheduling tools that support continuity of care, billing and compliance features built around Medicaid and state-specific requirements, and reporting that gives leadership visibility into both service quality and workforce trends. Just as important is evaluating the platform from a DSP's perspective, software that's efficient for administrators but burdensome for direct support staff will undermine retention rather than support it.

SETWorks icon

Subscribe to the SETWorks blog to stay up to date on all of our latest posts

SETWorks icon
Subscribe to stay up to date with the latest from SETWorks
SETWorks icon

Subscribe to stay up to date with the latest from SETWorks